← Back to News

Leny Yoro’s Red Card at Anfield Was the Wrong Call

Watch the video version of this story On @mavjonesdotcom, in about a minute. ▶ Play on TikTok
Graphic: Isak's touch was heavy, it wasn't a red. Leny Yoro was sent off in the eighth minute at Anfield for a foul on Alexander Isak and will miss Brentford.

Leny Yoro shouldn’t have been sent off. Samuel Barrott showed him a straight red card in the eighth minute at Anfield for bringing down Alexander Isak just outside the box, and our read of the replay is that Isak’s heavy touch had already pushed the ball away from him. A chance you’ve just knocked out of reach isn’t an obvious goalscoring opportunity, and that’s the whole case for a red.

Mauricio Pochettino’s first game lasted eight minutes at eleven against eleven. Dominik Szoboszlai scored the free kick on 10 minutes, Florian Wirtz made it 2-0 on 13, and it was still 2-0 at half-time.

▶ Follow @mavjonesdotcom on TikTok

What happened

It started with a ball forward from JĂ©rĂ©my Jacquet that Jamie Carragher, on Sky’s co-commentary, said “wasn’t even a pass, it was a clearance.” Matthijs de Ligt let it go. Goal reported that he “thought he could let a long ball run through to goalkeeper Senne Lammens”. He was wrong, Isak got there first, and Yoro came across and ran into the back of him outside the area.

Barrott showed a straight red, and that’s how the Premier League’s match data logs it. Goal reported that VAR, with John Brooks in the booth, made “a brief check” and let it stand.

What the law actually asks

A foul outside the box is only a red for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity if the opportunity was obvious. IFAB’s Law 12 lists four things the referee “must” consider:

  • distance between the offence and the goal
  • general direction of the play
  • likelihood of keeping or gaining control of the ball
  • location and number of defenders and attackers

The third one is the one that matters here. Isak was heading for goal and he was close to it, so the first two count against Yoro. But a striker who’s just knocked the ball too far ahead of himself, with a keeper behind it, isn’t in control of anything yet. That’s not a certain chance. It’s a race he might not win.

Even Gary Neville, who backed the red on Sky, saw something in it: “You could argue that Isak delays slightly, to make sure that Yoro runs into the back of him.” If Isak is slowing down to take the contact, he isn’t racing clear of it.

The case for the red

It’s fair to set out the other side, and most of the people who were watching it took it. Neville said: “And because he doesn’t play the ball, it’s outside the box, but it is a red card.” Then: “You’re not overturning that, no chance.” talkSPORT’s Ben Jacobs said Yoro “clumsily ran into Alexander Isak from behind when the Liverpool striker was completely free”.

That’s the real debate. Free of defenders, yes. Free with the ball under control, no. And VAR only steps in for a clear and obvious error, so a check that leaves a red card alone doesn’t prove the referee got it right. It only means the VAR didn’t think he’d got it badly wrong.

Yoro wasn’t the only one at fault

None of this makes it a good piece of defending. Neville said Yoro’s “positioning is poor” and that he had to be “across and around his centre-back”, and he’s right that a quicker read would never have needed the challenge. But the error that put him there was de Ligt’s. Neville said he was “absolutely stunned” to see de Ligt’s name on the team sheet. Harry Maguire, who started the 4-4 with Aston Villa, was on the bench, and Pochettino had to take off Bryan Mbeumo for him on 22 minutes to fix the back four. We questioned Maguire’s absence and two other selections before kick-off.

What it costs United

RotoWire reports Yoro will serve a one-match ban and miss Brentford on Saturday 28 November. The only way to get it cancelled is for the club to appeal it as a wrongful dismissal. We haven’t seen anything from United on whether they’ll lodge one. On this evidence, we would.

▶ Follow @mavjonesdotcom on TikTok

Sources: The minute of the red card, the goal times, the substitution, the half-time score, the referee and the VAR are from the Premier League’s match centre data, read at half-time on 22 November 2026; ESPN’s Opta commentary matches it. De Ligt’s misjudgement and the VAR check are from Goal and Goal, which also quotes Ben Jacobs. Neville’s and Carragher’s Sky Sports comments are as quoted by SPORTbible. The ban is from RotoWire. The four considerations are quoted from IFAB’s Law 12. That Isak’s touch was heavy, and that the red was the wrong call, is our own reading of the replay; none of the reports we read describes the touch.

Be the first to comment

Your email address will not be published. First-time comments are checked before they appear.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.