📅 November 5, 2026
No Caretaker Next Time: United Won’t Name an Interim if Carrick Goes
Watch the video version of this story On @mavjonesdotcom, in about a minute. ▶ Play on TikTok
If Manchester United decide to replace Michael Carrick, there won’t be another caretaker. Sky Sports reported on Thursday that the club is “unlikely to appoint another interim head coach” in the coming weeks. That changes what Sunday’s game against Aston Villa means: if Carrick goes, the next appointment is meant to be the permanent one.
And one name on the list is coming off it. Villa say Unai Emery has made “a clear commitment beyond 2029”, three days before he brings his side to Old Trafford.
▶ Follow @mavjonesdotcom on TikTok
What Sky is reporting
Rob Dorsett’s report says the international break next week gives the club a chance to “take a breath and reassess”, and that Sunday’s 4:30pm kick-off against Villa is a key game for Carrick’s future. Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada, who run football operations, are still weighing their options.
It isn’t one-way traffic. Sky says there’s still support for Carrick among the people above him, along with a worry that changing the coach might not fix the results. But the same report says there are doubts about the team’s direction and consistency, and that the preferred outcome is results improving so Carrick stays.
Julian Nagelsmann, Fabian Hürzeler and Eddie Howe are the names Sky describes as prominent in United’s thinking. Hürzeler is Brighton’s head coach, and no approach for any of the three has been reported.
Emery stays at Villa
Emery met Villa chairman Nassef Sawiris on Wednesday after Villa’s game in Barcelona. The club said afterwards that the talks established “a clear commitment beyond 2029 for the joint development of the club.” The Telegraph, via Goal, reports he’s extremely close to signing a new long-term deal, and BBC Sport, via dave, says the remaining talks are about length and money, with confirmation unlikely before the weekend. Nothing has been signed yet.
Emery had been widely discussed as a Carrick replacement, and Sky calls the new deal a blow to United. Practically, it means the man in the opposite dugout on Sunday has just chosen to stay where he is.
Where Carrick stands
Tuesday’s 3-2 win over Roma ended a run of nine games without a win, and it’s still the only win in his last ten. United are 17th in the Premier League, out of the bottom three on goal difference only. He was given the job on a two-year deal in May after his interim spell got United into the Champions League.
Roma bought him a few days, and he didn’t get carried away afterwards. Villa was always the second of the two games he was reportedly given before a review over the break.
Our view
No interim is the right call. United have had enough short-term managers, and a caretaker for the rest of the season would just put off the decision the club needs to make.
But it raises the stakes for Sunday. If the club won’t put a caretaker in, then sacking Carrick means having a permanent replacement ready, and with Emery off the table, that’s harder than it was a week ago. A result against Villa would make the decision easy to put off. A bad one would leave the club needing an answer it might not have yet.
▶ Follow @mavjonesdotcom on TikTok
Sources: The no-interim plan, the international break, Wilcox and Berrada, support for Carrick and doubts over direction, the three names, the Emery blow and Carrick’s record from Sky Sports (Rob Dorsett), 5 November 10:46 UK. Villa’s statement and Emery’s meeting from Goal, citing The Telegraph, and dave, citing BBC Sport. The no-interim report and the three names come from Sky alone, so they’re attributed. The Roma result and the league position from our earlier coverage. Our view is our own.