📅 October 26, 2026
Carrick Left Hanging: United’s Silence Is the Whole Season in One Day
Watch the video version of this story On @mavjonesdotcom, in about a minute. ▶ Play on TikTok
Michael Carrick spent Monday afternoon at Carrington watching the Under-21s play Hull behind closed doors, while the two men deciding whether to sack him talked about it somewhere else in the building. He left just before 5pm, shortly after Jason Wilcox. By Monday evening United still hadn’t said a word.
That’s not a one-off. It’s the season in one afternoon. Decisions arrive late, everyone hears the arguments in public first, and the people at the top only show up in the reporting, never in their own words.
▶ Follow @mavjonesdotcom on TikTok
What happened on Monday
Omar Berrada and Wilcox held talks at Carrington about Carrick’s future, as ESPN reported. Carrick got there shortly before 2pm and stayed about three hours. The players had the day off and are back on Tuesday. ESPN’s line by the evening was that the club was “still not tipping its hand”.
Sky Sports’ Rob Dorsett says insiders expect Carrick to be “relieved of his duties”. The process is that Berrada and Wilcox make a recommendation and Sir Jim Ratcliffe has the final say. Gary Neville predicted on Sunday night that the decision would come “tomorrow”. It didn’t.
Inside the building, it’s no better. Stretty News reports that staff “have yet to receive any sort of communication”. Carrick said after the Bournemouth game, as the Evening Standard reported: “What’s next, I really do not know.” A day later, nobody else seemed to know either.
Everyone already knows the replacements
The head coach hasn’t been sacked, but his successors are already a public debate. Sky reports that Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann are the front-runners, that both could start quickly and that neither would cost compensation. ESPN’s sources name the same two.
Sky says the people in charge don’t even agree on that. Wilcox is thought to want a coach with Premier League experience, which points to Howe. Christopher Vivell, the head of recruitment, worked with Nagelsmann at RB Leipzig. So the club can’t decide whether to sack its manager, and it’s already split on who should replace him.
If Carrick’s still in charge when the players report on Tuesday, he walks in knowing all of that. So do they.
The players said it first
None of this came from nowhere. After the 2-0 loss in Madrid on 13 October, Lisandro Martínez told Amazon Prime: “Yeah, 100 per cent. I expect more from our technical director.” Then he said the line that reads differently tonight: “You start changing, changing, changing managers. But what about other areas? I can’t say more.”
Eight days later, after the 4-1 at Como, it was the captain’s turn. Bruno Fernandes told TNT the pressing plan was “a decision from the staff” and added: “That’s on the manager and on the staff to see it, it’s not on me.” Carrick replied in his press conference that “whatever tactics you play, if you don’t run,” it doesn’t work.
A senior defender went public about recruitment, the captain went public about the coaching, and the coach answered in a press conference. At a functioning club, someone above all three of them steps in. Here the only public response from above was silence.
A decision put off once already
The club already faced this choice after Como. On 22 October they let Carrick take Bournemouth, and ESPN reported the hierarchy would accept a change if results didn’t turn quickly. Sky reported that the bosses believed this squad was stronger than the one that finished third last season.
Then Carrick dropped Bruno for Bournemouth, left him on the bench for all 90 minutes, and United lost 3-0 at home. The fans sang Carrick’s name and aimed the anger at the Glazers, Ratcliffe and Wilcox, as Sky, ESPN and DPA all reported. The decision they’d put off didn’t get any easier. It got worse, and it’s still not made.
What the club has become
It’s a club that lets a captain and the manager argue through the TV cameras for a week and says nothing. It’s a club where the next manager’s shortlist is in print before the current one has been told anything. And it’s a club where the head coach says “What’s next, I really do not know” and the reporting fills in the rest.
Our view hasn’t changed since Sunday: Carrick should go. But the way you do it matters. If the decision’s made, announce it and have a plan for Chelsea. If it isn’t, say he’s staying and back him in public. Leaving him to face the players on Tuesday as a dead man walking is the worst of both, and it’s exactly how this whole season has been run.
United are 16th, one point above the relegation zone, and go to Chelsea on Saturday 31 October at 12.30pm UK. Roma at home in the Champions League follows on 3 November. Whoever’s in the dugout at Stamford Bridge should know before the players report on Tuesday.
▶ Follow @mavjonesdotcom on TikTok
Sources: Monday’s talks, Carrick’s times at Carrington, the training schedule and “still not tipping its hand” from ESPN, 26 October; the Daily Mail’s Chris Wheeler also reported Carrick and Wilcox leaving, via Stretty News on Yahoo Sports, which is also the source for the staff quote. The insiders’ expectation, the recommendation-to-Ratcliffe process, Howe and Nagelsmann, and Wilcox and Vivell from Sky Sports (Rob Dorsett), 26 October; ESPN’s sources also name Howe and Nagelsmann. Neville’s “tomorrow” line from Sky Sports. Carrick’s “What’s next” quote from the Evening Standard via Yahoo Sports, the only outlet we found carrying it, so it’s attributed. Martínez, Fernandes, the 22 October decision, the squad-strength report and the Bournemouth crowd from our earlier coverage, linked above. Table and fixtures from the Premier League and UEFA via our earlier reporting. Left out: the length of United’s winless run, because Sky and ESPN don’t agree on it.